Best Gun Shops in Shelter Island Heights

A family-owned institution since 1956, Camp-Site Sport Shop is one of Long Island's most respected firearms dealers. While located in Huntington Station, they serve customers throughout Suffolk County including Shelter Island residents. They offer an extensive selection of handguns, rifles, and shotguns from top manufacturers, along with comprehensive gunsmithing services and firearm safety courses. Their knowledgeable staff provides exceptional customer service and they maintain one of the region's best inventories of hunting and shooting accessories.

Located in Riverhead, DSI has been serving Eastern Long Island since 1999 and is easily accessible to Shelter Island residents. They specialize in law enforcement and civilian firearms with an impressive selection of modern sporting rifles, handguns, and tactical gear. Their certified gunsmiths provide repair, customization, and maintenance services. DSI is known for their professional staff, comprehensive training programs, and excellent customer service, making them a top choice for both new and experienced shooters in the region.

Serving the South Fork and Shelter Island area, Hampton Guns & Tackle has built an excellent reputation since opening in 2012. They offer a carefully curated selection of hunting firearms, sporting shotguns, and personal defense handguns. Their knowledgeable staff provides personalized service and they offer comprehensive gunsmithing services, firearm safety courses, and hunting license sales. Located in Hampton Bays, they're conveniently accessible to Shelter Island residents and known for their expertise in local hunting regulations and conditions.