Best Gun Shops in Shelter Island

South Shore Sportsman is a premier firearms destination serving the East End, including Shelter Island via the North Ferry. This family-owned shop has built an exceptional reputation for its extensive inventory of handguns, rifles, and shotguns from top manufacturers. Their on-site gunsmithing services are highly regarded, handling everything from basic repairs to custom builds. The knowledgeable staff provides personalized service and comprehensive training programs, making them a top choice for both new and experienced shooters in the Hamptons area.

Dark Storm Industries is a highly specialized firearms manufacturer and retailer serving Long Island and accessible to Shelter Island residents. They've earned their strong reputation through expertise in AR-15 platform firearms, offering both complete rifles and custom builds. Their retail showroom features an impressive selection of firearms and accessories, complemented by professional gunsmithing services. Known for their technical expertise and compliance knowledge, DSI is particularly popular among enthusiasts seeking high-quality modern sporting rifles and custom solutions.

Located in Riverhead, Hunter Essentials serves as a comprehensive outdoor sports destination for Shelter Island residents. They offer a well-curated selection of firearms with a focus on hunting applications, along with extensive ammunition inventory and shooting accessories. The staff is known for their friendly, knowledgeable service and commitment to helping customers find the right equipment for their needs. Their convenient North Fork location makes them easily accessible, and they've built a loyal customer base through consistent, reliable service and competitive pricing.