Best Gun Shops in Sag Harbor

Family-owned and operated since 1957, Campsite Sport Shop is one of Long Island's most respected firearms dealers serving the entire region including Sag Harbor. They offer an extensive selection of handguns, rifles, and shotguns from top manufacturers, along with comprehensive gunsmithing services. The knowledgeable staff provides exceptional customer service and expert guidance for both novice and experienced shooters. Their long-standing reputation, extensive inventory of firearms and ammunition, and commitment to the shooting sports community make them a top choice for Eastern Long Island residents.

South Shore Sportsman has been serving Long Island's firearms community since 1989 with an outstanding reputation for expertise and customer service. They feature a massive showroom with one of the region's largest selections of firearms, including hard-to-find models and collectibles. The shop includes an indoor shooting range and offers comprehensive training programs. Their expert gunsmithing department handles everything from simple repairs to custom builds. Despite being located further west, they regularly serve customers from across Long Island including Sag Harbor due to their unparalleled inventory and service quality.

Established in 1999, DSI Dunhams Sportsman has built a strong reputation as one of Nassau County's premier firearms dealers, serving the entire Long Island region including Sag Harbor. They specialize in both modern sporting firearms and classic collectibles, with knowledgeable staff who provide personalized service. The shop offers comprehensive gunsmithing services, FFL transfers, and maintains excellent inventory levels even during high-demand periods. Their commitment to customer education and responsible firearms ownership, combined with competitive pricing and reliable service, makes them a trusted destination for Eastern Long Island shooters.