Best Gun Shops in Fishers Island, New York

Top 3 gun shops in Fishers Island, ranked by our evaluation system.Rated 4.5 out of 5average from 366 reviews

1
Colonial Gunsmith
Colonial Gunsmith LLC
Rated 4.7 out of 5158 reviews
Colonial Gunsmith is a highly respected, family-owned shop known for its expert gunsmithing services and extensive inventory of firearms, including handguns, rifles, and shotguns. With a focus on customer education and safety, they offer comprehensive training courses and personalized service. Their convenient location in New London, CT, makes them easily accessible to Fishers Island residents via ferry, and they are praised for their knowledgeable staff and reliable transfers.
- Firearms Sales
- Gunsmithing
- Training
- Transfers
- Accessories
- Ammunition
345 Bank St, New London, CT 06320
19 years in business
Call(860) 442-5430 Search online(opens in a new tab)
2
The Gun Store
The Gun Store Inc.
Rated 4.4 out of 5132 reviews
The Gun Store provides a wide selection of new and used firearms, along with ammunition and accessories, in a professional and welcoming environment. They are renowned for their concealed carry and safety training programs, staffed by experienced instructors. Located just minutes from the New London ferry, they serve the Fishers Island community with efficient transfers and excellent customer support, making them a top choice for both beginners and seasoned enthusiasts.
- Firearms Sales
- Training
- Transfers
- Accessories
- Ammunition
595 Hartford Turnpike, Waterford, CT 06385
22 years in business
Call(860) 442-5940 Search online(opens in a new tab)
3
D&J Gun Shop
D&J Gun Shop LLC
Rated 4.5 out of 576 reviews
D&J Gun Shop is a family-operated business offering a diverse range of firearms, from modern tactical to classic models, alongside gunsmithing and transfer services. Known for their friendly, knowledgeable approach and commitment to customer satisfaction, they cater to hunters, sport shooters, and collectors throughout southeastern Connecticut, including Fishers Island. Their personalized service and strong community ties have earned them a loyal customer base.
- Firearms Sales
- Gunsmithing
- Transfers
- Accessories
- Ammunition
2 W Main St, Norwich, CT 06360
15 years in business
Call(860) 889-1744 Search online(opens in a new tab)

Think you should be listed here?

If you operate a licensed firearms dealer in Fishers Island, New York and believe your shop deserves a spot on our list, we'd love to hear from you. Contact our editorial team to get started.

Get in Touch

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about gun shops in Fishers Island, New York

Are there any gun shops physically located on Fishers Island, NY?

No, there are no dedicated gun shops physically located on Fishers Island itself. Residents typically travel to the mainland in New York or Connecticut to access firearms retailers like Colonial Gunsmith, The Gun Store, or D&J Gun Shop. All firearms purchases and transfers for Fishers Island residents must comply with New York State laws, regardless of where the transaction occurs.

What is the process for purchasing a firearm as a Fishers Island, NY resident?

As a New York resident, you must obtain a pistol permit from Suffolk County for handguns or complete a NICS background check for long guns at a licensed dealer. Since there are no dealers on the island, you must complete the purchase and transfer at a mainland FFL holder. For handguns, you'll need to add the specific firearm to your permit through the county clerk's office before taking possession.

Can Fishers Island residents use gun shops in Connecticut for purchases?

Yes, but with important restrictions. While you can purchase long guns from dealers in Connecticut under federal law, they must comply with New York's assault weapons ban and feature restrictions. Handgun purchases by New York residents from Connecticut dealers are generally not permitted, as the handgun must be transferred through a New York FFL holder to comply with state permit requirements and registration.

What specific New York State regulations affect Fishers Island gun owners?

Fishers Island residents must comply with all New York SAFE Act regulations, including the assault weapons ban, 10-round magazine capacity limit, and universal background checks. Additionally, all handguns must be registered on your New York pistol permit, and ammunition purchases now require a background check through a licensed dealer. These regulations apply regardless of where you purchase your firearms.

Where can Fishers Island residents find gunsmithing or repair services?

Since no gunsmiths operate on Fishers Island, residents must transport firearms to mainland providers. Colonial Gunsmith and other nearby shops offer gunsmithing services for repairs, modifications, and maintenance. Remember that transporting firearms between New York and Connecticut requires compliance with both states' transportation laws, particularly for handguns which must be unloaded and secured during transit.

Finding Certified Gun Stores on Fishers Island, NY: Your Guide to Quality & Compliance

This guide explains the importance of federally and state-certified gun stores for Fishers Island, NY residents, highlighting how local shops like Colonial Gunsmith provide essential expertise on compliance and safety in a unique island community.

For gun enthusiasts on Fishers Island, New York, finding a reliable, certified gun store isn't just about convenience—it's about trust, safety, and ensuring your transactions are handled with the utmost professionalism. Living on an island community like ours means your local gun shop is more than a retailer; it's a neighbor and a crucial part of our responsible firearms culture. Understanding what makes a gun store 'certified' and knowing where to find these trusted establishments is essential for every firearm owner here.

When we talk about 'certified gun stores,' we're generally referring to dealers who hold a valid Federal Firearms License (FFL) from the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF). This federal certification is non-negotiable for any business legally selling firearms. In New York State, and particularly for us in Fishers Island, this is just the starting point. Reputable local shops like Colonial Gunsmith, The Gun Store, and D&J Gun Shop operate with this fundamental certification, but the best among them go further. They often have staff certified through programs like the NRA's Certified Instructor courses or state-specific safety training, ensuring they can provide expert guidance on New York's complex firearm laws, including SAFE Act compliance.

Why does this local certification matter so much for Fishers Island residents? First, our geographic isolation means you can't just drive to the next town over if you have a question about a transfer or need urgent gunsmithing. Building a relationship with a certified, knowledgeable local dealer is practical. These professionals understand the specific needs of island life—whether you're a sport shooter, a hunter managing local populations, or a responsible citizen seeking home defense. They can guide you through the required NYS background checks and paperwork with accuracy, preventing frustrating delays.

When visiting shops like Colonial Gunsmith or D&J Gun Shop, look for signs of their commitment beyond the basic FFL. Do they prominently display their licenses? Are staff able to clearly explain state and local regulations? A truly certified store will make compliance education a part of their service. They should be your first stop for understanding safe storage laws in New York or navigating the process for pistol permits in Suffolk County.

For Fishers Island gun owners, my advice is this: prioritize stores that view their certification as a commitment to community safety, not just a legal requirement. Ask questions about their staff's training, their familiarity with island-specific considerations (like transporting firearms on and off the island), and their after-sales support. A certified gun store in our community should be a partner in responsible ownership, helping you enjoy your Second Amendment rights while fully respecting the laws that keep us all safe. By supporting these locally certified businesses, you invest in the expertise and ethical standards that make our island's firearms community strong.

About Fishers Island, New York

Fishers Island gun owners and enthusiasts deserve quality service when choosing a firearms dealer. Our featured shops specialize in firearms sales, gunsmithing, and training services with expert staff in New York.

Local Expertise: Shops familiar with Fishers Island community and local firearms needs.
Trusted Service: Licensed and reputable dealers with proven service records in Fishers Island.
Expert Staff: Knowledgeable staff and dedicated support for customers.