Best Gun Shops in Cayuga

The Firing Pin is widely regarded as the premier firearms retailer in the Cayuga County area, located just 15 minutes from Cayuga in Auburn. This family-owned shop has built an exceptional reputation for outstanding customer service and extensive inventory of new and used firearms. Their knowledgeable staff provides expert guidance for both new and experienced shooters, offering comprehensive gunsmithing services, CCW classes, and specialty items including NFA firearms. The shop maintains a clean, professional environment with a focus on education and safety.

Located approximately 12 miles from Cayuga, Auburn Trap & Field offers a unique combination of retail firearms sales and extensive shooting facilities. This established business features a full-service gun shop with quality firearms from major manufacturers, complemented by outdoor trap and skeet ranges. The staff includes certified instructors who provide comprehensive training programs including hunter safety and defensive shooting courses. Their commitment to the shooting sports community and well-maintained facilities make them a top destination for both recreational and serious shooters in the region.

Seneca Gun Works serves the Cayuga area from their Seneca Falls location approximately 20 minutes away. This highly-rated shop specializes in both commercial firearms sales and expert gunsmithing services. Their skilled gunsmiths handle everything from basic repairs to complex custom work, earning praise for their craftsmanship and turnaround time. The retail section features a carefully curated selection of handguns, rifles, and shotguns from quality manufacturers, with staff known for their patient, knowledgeable approach to helping customers find the right firearm for their needs.