Best Gun Shops in Caledonia, New York

Top 3 gun shops in Caledonia, ranked by our evaluation system.Rated 4.5 out of 5average from 394 reviews

1
Runnings
Rated 4.2 out of 585 reviews
Runnings is a well-established regional outdoor and farm supply store located just 10 minutes from Caledonia. Their firearms department features a substantial selection of rifles, shotguns, and handguns from major manufacturers, along with extensive ammunition inventory. The staff includes knowledgeable firearms specialists who provide excellent customer service and guidance. As a larger retailer, they offer competitive pricing and regular promotions, making them a popular choice for local hunters and shooting enthusiasts in the Livingston County area.
- Firearms Sales
- Ammunition
- Hunting Gear
- Outdoor Equipment
- Fishing Supplies
- Clothing
4220 Veterans Memorial Dr, Avon, NY 14414
8 years in business
Call(585) 226-8500 Search online(opens in a new tab)
2
The Firing Pin
The Firing Pin LLC
Rated 4.8 out of 5142 reviews
Located approximately 15 minutes from Caledonia, The Firing Pin has earned exceptional reviews for their professional staff expertise and comprehensive services. They operate both a full-service gun shop and indoor shooting range, offering everything from beginner firearms training to advanced tactical courses. Their gunsmithing services are highly regarded, with quick turnaround times for repairs and custom work. The shop maintains a carefully curated selection of new and used firearms, with particular strength in defensive handguns and modern sporting rifles.
- Firearms Sales
- Gunsmithing
- Training Classes
- Transfers
- Range Memberships
- Concealed Carry Courses
7950 State Route 19, Bergen, NY 14416
12 years in business
Call(585) 813-8160 Search online(opens in a new tab)
3
American Sportsman
Rated 4.6 out of 5167 reviews
While located in Penfield (approximately 25 minutes from Caledonia), American Sportsman has served the greater Rochester region for over two decades with outstanding reputation. They feature one of the most extensive firearms inventories in Western New York, including rare and collectible pieces alongside standard offerings. Their gunsmithing department is staffed by experienced professionals capable of handling complex repairs and custom builds. Customers consistently praise the knowledgeable staff, fair pricing, and exceptional customer service that has made them a destination shop for serious firearms enthusiasts throughout the region.
- Firearms Sales
- Gunsmithing
- Transfers
- Ammunition
- Hunting Supplies
- Archery Equipment
2132 Penfield Rd, Penfield, NY 14526
25 years in business
Call(585) 381-4340 Search online(opens in a new tab)

Think you should be listed here?

If you operate a licensed firearms dealer in Caledonia, New York and believe your shop deserves a spot on our list, we'd love to hear from you. Contact our editorial team to get started.

Get in Touch

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about gun shops in Caledonia, New York

What are the main gun shops in Caledonia, NY, and what services do they offer?

The primary gun shops in Caledonia, NY, include Runnings, The Firing Pin, and American Sportsman. These shops typically offer firearms sales, ammunition, accessories, and FFL transfer services. Some may also provide gunsmithing, training, or hunting supplies, so it's best to contact them directly for specific offerings.

What are the key New York State firearm regulations I need to know when purchasing a gun in Caledonia?

When purchasing a firearm in Caledonia, NY, you must comply with New York State laws, including background checks for all sales, a waiting period for handguns, and SAFE Act requirements like magazine capacity limits. An NYS pistol permit is required for handgun purchases, and semi-automatic rifles may need additional registration. Always consult with local shops like The Firing Pin for current regulations.

How does the pistol permit process work for Caledonia residents in New York?

Caledonia residents must apply for a pistol permit through the Livingston County Clerk's Office, as it's a county-level process in New York. This involves submitting an application, fingerprints, references, and possibly completing a safety course. The process can take several months, and once approved, you can purchase handguns from licensed dealers like American Sportsman in Caledonia.

Do gun shops in Caledonia, NY, offer firearm training or safety courses?

Yes, some gun shops in Caledonia, such as The Firing Pin, may offer or recommend firearm training and safety courses, which are often required for NYS pistol permits. These courses cover safe handling, storage, and state laws. It's advisable to check with individual shops for scheduled classes or local instructor referrals.

Can I perform a private firearm transfer through a gun shop in Caledonia, and what are the requirements?

Yes, gun shops in Caledonia like Runnings or American Sportsman can facilitate private firearm transfers as licensed FFL dealers. New York State requires all private sales to go through an FFL for a background check, even for long guns. You'll need to bring the firearm and valid ID to the shop, pay a transfer fee, and complete the necessary paperwork.

Finding the Right Licensed Gun Store in Caledonia, NY: A Local Guide for Firearms Enthusiasts

This guide helps Caledonia, NY firearms enthusiasts navigate local licensed gun stores like Runnings, The Firing Pin, and American Sportsman, emphasizing their role in providing expert guidance, ensuring regulatory compliance, and fostering responsible ownership within the community.

For firearms enthusiasts in Caledonia, New York, choosing the right licensed gun store is about more than just making a purchase—it's about finding a trusted partner in your shooting journey. Licensed gun stores in our area serve as crucial hubs for education, community, and responsible ownership, all while operating within New York's specific regulatory framework. Whether you're a seasoned collector or a first-time buyer navigating the Finger Lakes region, understanding what sets local licensed retailers apart can significantly enhance your experience.

In Caledonia, we're fortunate to have several established licensed gun stores that cater to different needs. Runnings offers a broad selection of firearms and outdoor gear under one roof, making it a convenient stop for hunters and recreational shooters stocking up for seasons in the nearby Genesee Valley. The Firing Pin, known for its specialized focus, provides a more curated experience, often appealing to enthusiasts interested in specific models, accessories, or deeper technical knowledge. American Sportsman rounds out the local options with its established reputation, potentially offering services like transfers, gunsmithing consultations, or special orders. Each of these New York State-licensed dealers must comply with rigorous background check requirements, waiting periods, and safe storage laws, which reputable stores will transparently guide you through.

The true value of a licensed gun store in Caledonia extends beyond the counter. These establishments are staffed by knowledgeable professionals who can demystify New York's SAFE Act regulations, advise on compliant firearm features, and recommend suitable options for target shooting at local ranges like the nearby Genesee Conservation League or hunting in the surrounding Livingston County woods. Building a relationship with your local dealer means having a reliable source for questions about maintenance, upcoming legislation, or the paperwork required for a pistol permit in Livingston County.

When visiting licensed gun stores in our area, come prepared with your New York State driver's license and, if applicable, your pistol permit. Don't hesitate to ask specific questions about their inventory sourcing, gunsmithing services, or their process for handling National Instant Criminal Background Check System (NICS) checks. Supporting these local businesses also strengthens our community of responsible gun owners. Before your next purchase or transfer, consider what each Caledonia retailer offers—whether it's the convenience of a big-box selection, the specialized expertise of a dedicated shop, or the full-service approach of a longstanding dealer. Your choice supports local commerce and ensures you have expert guidance right here in Western New York.

About Caledonia, New York

Caledonia gun owners and enthusiasts deserve quality service when choosing a firearms dealer. Our featured shops specialize in firearms sales, gunsmithing, and training services with expert staff in New York.

Local Expertise: Shops familiar with Caledonia community and local firearms needs.
Trusted Service: Licensed and reputable dealers with proven service records in Caledonia.
Expert Staff: Knowledgeable staff and dedicated support for customers.