Best Gun Shops in Caledonia

Runnings is a well-established regional outdoor and farm supply store located just 10 minutes from Caledonia. Their firearms department features a substantial selection of rifles, shotguns, and handguns from major manufacturers, along with extensive ammunition inventory. The staff includes knowledgeable firearms specialists who provide excellent customer service and guidance. As a larger retailer, they offer competitive pricing and regular promotions, making them a popular choice for local hunters and shooting enthusiasts in the Livingston County area.

Located approximately 15 minutes from Caledonia, The Firing Pin has earned exceptional reviews for their professional staff expertise and comprehensive services. They operate both a full-service gun shop and indoor shooting range, offering everything from beginner firearms training to advanced tactical courses. Their gunsmithing services are highly regarded, with quick turnaround times for repairs and custom work. The shop maintains a carefully curated selection of new and used firearms, with particular strength in defensive handguns and modern sporting rifles.

While located in Penfield (approximately 25 minutes from Caledonia), American Sportsman has served the greater Rochester region for over two decades with outstanding reputation. They feature one of the most extensive firearms inventories in Western New York, including rare and collectible pieces alongside standard offerings. Their gunsmithing department is staffed by experienced professionals capable of handling complex repairs and custom builds. Customers consistently praise the knowledgeable staff, fair pricing, and exceptional customer service that has made them a destination shop for serious firearms enthusiasts throughout the region.