Best Gun Shops in Bayville

A long-standing local institution in Bayville, this family-owned sport shop has served the community for over four decades. While primarily a full-service sporting goods store, they maintain a solid selection of firearms including hunting rifles, shotguns, and related accessories. Known for their personalized service and deep local knowledge, the staff provides expert guidance on firearm selection for both hunting and sport shooting. Their convenient Bayville location makes them the most accessible option for local residents, with a reputation for fair pricing and reliable service.

Located approximately 15 miles from Bayville in Island Park, this large sporting goods retailer offers an extensive firearms department with competitive pricing on a wide variety of handguns, rifles, and shotguns from major manufacturers. As part of a national chain with deep buying power, they frequently have excellent inventory levels and regular sales. The firearms staff receives specialized training and the store maintains a strong reputation for proper paperwork handling and compliance. Their broad selection of ammunition and accessories makes them a popular destination for shooters throughout Nassau County.

A highly-rated specialty firearms dealer located about 12 miles from Bayville in Lynbrook, Hunter Essentials has built an outstanding reputation for exceptional customer service and expertise. They specialize in both modern sporting firearms and classic hunting weapons, with a particular focus on personalized service. The shop offers comprehensive gunsmithing services, FFL transfers, and maintains one of the better ammunition selections in the area. Customers consistently praise the knowledgeable staff, fair pricing, and the shop's commitment to educating new gun owners. Their training programs and commitment to safety make them a top choice for both experienced shooters and first-time buyers.