Best Gun Shops in Baldwin

Coliseum Gun Traders is a legendary firearms destination serving the Baldwin area and all of Long Island. With over six decades in business, they've built an exceptional reputation for their massive inventory of new and used firearms, comprehensive gunsmithing services, and state-of-the-art indoor shooting range. Their knowledgeable staff provides expert guidance to both novice and experienced shooters, offering extensive training programs and professional transfers. The shop maintains a 4.8-star rating across multiple review platforms, with customers consistently praising their outstanding customer service, fair pricing, and extensive selection of firearms and accessories.

Hunter Sports has been serving the Baldwin and South Shore communities since 1970, establishing itself as one of Long Island's premier firearms retailers. This family-owned business excels in personalized service and expert knowledge, offering an impressive selection of handguns, rifles, and shotguns from top manufacturers. Their in-house gunsmithing department provides reliable repairs and custom work, while their transfer services are among the most efficient in the region. With a 4.7-star rating, customers frequently highlight the staff's professionalism, extensive product knowledge, and commitment to ensuring customers find exactly what they need.

DSI Dunhams Sports has been a trusted firearms retailer serving the Baldwin area since 1997, offering a comprehensive selection of firearms, ammunition, and shooting accessories. As part of a respected regional chain, they combine the buying power of a larger organization with local expertise and service. Their knowledgeable staff provides excellent guidance on firearm selection and compliance with New York state regulations. The shop maintains strong relationships with major manufacturers, ensuring a consistent inventory of popular models. With a 4.6-star rating, customers appreciate their competitive pricing, well-organized showroom, and professional approach to firearms sales and transfers.