Best Gun Shops in Stirling

Ottomanelli's is widely regarded as one of New Jersey's premier firearm destinations, located just 15 minutes from Stirling. This family-owned establishment has built an exceptional reputation over 25 years for their extensive inventory of handguns, rifles, and shotguns, plus a full-service gunsmithing department that handles everything from basic repairs to custom builds. Their knowledgeable staff provides excellent customer service and they offer comprehensive training courses, NFA services, and one of the largest accessory selections in North Jersey. The shop maintains consistently high ratings for their expertise and professional approach to firearm sales and services.

Located approximately 20 minutes from Stirling in the heart of Long Valley, this unique establishment combines a firearms dealer with a traditional country store and pub. Long Valley Supply has earned outstanding reviews for their friendly, knowledgeable service and carefully curated selection of quality firearms. They specialize in sporting arms, home defense weapons, and hunting equipment, with a focus on personalized customer service. Their gunsmithing services are highly regarded, and they maintain an excellent reputation for fair pricing and honest advice in the firearms community.

While located about 30 minutes from Stirling in Paramus, Ramsey Outdoor has served New Jersey shooters for decades with one of the largest and most established firearms departments in the region. Their extensive inventory includes handguns, rifles, shotguns, and a comprehensive selection of ammunition and accessories. The firearms staff receives consistent praise for their expertise and professional service. As a full-line outdoor retailer, they offer everything from hunting equipment to range gear, making them a one-stop destination for firearms enthusiasts throughout Northern New Jersey.