Best Gun Shops in Stillwater, New Jersey

Top 3 gun shops in Stillwater, ranked by our evaluation system.Rated 4.7 out of 5average from 430 reviews

1
The Gun Rack
Rated 4.7 out of 5150 reviews
The Gun Rack is a highly regarded independent shop located just minutes from Stillwater, known for its exceptional customer service and deep expertise in firearms. They offer a wide selection of new and used guns, comprehensive gunsmithing services, and specialized training programs. With a focus on personalized service and community engagement, they have built a strong reputation in Sussex County for reliability and knowledge.
- Firearms Sales
- Gunsmithing
- Training
- Transfers
- Accessories
- Ammunition
- Archery
100 Route 23, Sussex, NJ 07461
19 years in business
Call(973) 875-5199 Search online(opens in a new tab)
2
A&S Gun Shop
Rated 4.6 out of 5100 reviews
A&S Gun Shop is a family-owned business in Newton, serving the Stillwater area with a commitment to quality and expertise. They provide a curated inventory of firearms, reliable gunsmithing, and efficient transfer services. Customers praise their friendly staff, fair pricing, and willingness to educate buyers, making it a trusted destination for both beginners and seasoned enthusiasts in Sussex County.
- Firearms Sales
- Gunsmithing
- Transfers
- Accessories
- Ammunition
- Custom Orders
145 Spring St, Newton, NJ 07860
24 years in business
Call(973) 579-6868 Search online(opens in a new tab)
3
Cheyenne Mountain Outfitters
Rated 4.8 out of 5180 reviews
As a premier regional firearms retailer, Cheyenne Mountain Outfitters serves customers from Stillwater and beyond with an extensive inventory and professional services. They are known for their vast selection of firearms, expert gunsmithing, and top-rated safety training courses. Despite being farther away, their reputation for excellence, knowledgeable staff, and comprehensive offerings make them a worthwhile destination for serious gun owners in New Jersey.
- Firearms Sales
- Gunsmithing
- Training
- Transfers
- Accessories
- Ammunition
- Outdoor Gear
1944 Route 206, Bordentown, NJ 08505
25 years in business
Call(609) 298-4867 Search online(opens in a new tab)

Think you should be listed here?

If you operate a licensed firearms dealer in Stillwater, New Jersey and believe your shop deserves a spot on our list, we'd love to hear from you. Contact our editorial team to get started.

Get in Touch

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about gun shops in Stillwater, New Jersey

What are the main gun shops in Stillwater, NJ, and what services do they typically offer?

The primary gun shops in Stillwater, NJ, include The Gun Rack, A&S Gun Shop, and Cheyenne Mountain Outfitters. These shops typically offer firearms sales, FFL transfers, ammunition, accessories, and basic gunsmithing services. Some may also provide safety training or hunting licenses, though availability varies by location.

What are the key New Jersey state regulations I need to know before purchasing a firearm in Stillwater?

New Jersey has strict firearm regulations, including a Firearms Purchaser ID Card (FPIC) required for all purchases, a 7-day waiting period for handguns, and a one-handgun-per-30-days limit. Additionally, New Jersey prohibits assault firearms and high-capacity magazines over 10 rounds, which gun shops in Stillwater must comply with.

How does the firearm purchasing process work at a gun shop in Stillwater, NJ?

To purchase a firearm in Stillwater, you must first obtain a New Jersey Firearms Purchaser ID Card through your local police department, which includes a background check and fingerprinting. For handguns, you'll also need a separate permit per purchase. Gun shops like The Gun Rack or A&S Gun Shop will facilitate the transfer after verifying your documents and conducting a NICS check.

Do gun shops in Stillwater, NJ, offer firearm training or safety courses?

Some gun shops in Stillwater, such as Cheyenne Mountain Outfitters, may offer basic firearm safety or hunter education courses, but availability is limited. For comprehensive training, residents often seek certified instructors or ranges outside Stillwater, as New Jersey requires training for certain permits like the Permit to Carry a Handgun.

Can I perform a private party firearm transfer through a gun shop in Stillwater, and what are the requirements?

Yes, gun shops in Stillwater like The Gun Rack or A&S Gun Shop can facilitate private party transfers as licensed FFLs. Both parties must be present with valid ID and FPIC cards, and the shop will conduct a background check and complete state-mandated paperwork. Transfers must comply with New Jersey laws, including assault firearm and magazine restrictions.

Finding the Best Gun Shops Near Me in Stillwater, NJ: A Local Enthusiast's Guide

This guide explores Stillwater, NJ's local gun shops—The Gun Rack, A&S Gun Shop, and Cheyenne Mountain Outfitters—offering practical advice for enthusiasts on selecting the right shop based on their specific needs, building relationships with local experts, and navigating New Jersey's firearms regulations in our semi-rural community.

When you search for 'gun shops near me' in Stillwater, New Jersey, you're not just looking for a store—you're seeking a trusted partner in your firearms journey. As a gun enthusiast in Sussex County, you understand that the right shop can make all the difference, whether you're a seasoned collector, a hunter preparing for the upcoming season in the Delaware Water Gap region, or a responsible citizen pursuing your Second Amendment rights. Stillwater offers several excellent options, each with its own unique character and specialties.

Let's start with The Gun Rack, a local favorite known for its personalized service and extensive selection of hunting rifles and shotguns. Their staff understands the specific needs of Stillwater hunters who pursue deer, turkey, and small game in our surrounding woodlands. They can help you select the right firearm for New Jersey's specific hunting regulations and the terrain you'll encounter in Stokes State Forest or the Kittatinny Mountains.

A&S Gun Shop brings a different strength to our community—their gunsmithing services are particularly valuable for enthusiasts who need repairs, custom work, or maintenance on their firearms. In a rural area like Stillwater, having a skilled gunsmith nearby is essential, especially when you need quick turnaround before hunting season or a competition. Their expertise with both modern firearms and classics makes them a go-to resource for collectors and practical shooters alike.

Cheyenne Mountain Outfitters offers a broader outdoor experience, combining firearms with other gear for the complete Stillwater outdoorsperson. Their approach is particularly helpful for those who want to discuss not just the firearm itself, but how it fits into their overall outdoor activities in Northwest New Jersey.

When visiting any Stillwater gun shop, come prepared with your New Jersey Firearms ID Card and be ready to discuss your specific needs. Mention local hunting opportunities, home defense considerations in our semi-rural community, or target shooting options at nearby ranges like Cherry Ridge Range in Vernon. Building a relationship with your local shop pays dividends—they'll notify you about new arrivals that match your interests, help with NJ's compliance requirements, and provide insights about local shooting opportunities.

Remember that 'gun shops near me' in Stillwater aren't just retail outlets—they're community hubs where you can exchange information about local conditions, learn about changes in New Jersey firearms laws, and connect with fellow enthusiasts. Take time to visit each establishment, ask questions specific to our region, and support these local businesses that serve our unique needs in Sussex County. Whether you're looking for your first firearm or adding to a collection, Stillwater's gun shops offer the expertise and personalized attention that big-box stores simply can't match.

About Stillwater, New Jersey

Stillwater gun owners and enthusiasts deserve quality service when choosing a firearms dealer. Our featured shops specialize in firearms sales, gunsmithing, and training services with expert staff in New Jersey.

Local Expertise: Shops familiar with Stillwater community and local firearms needs.
Trusted Service: Licensed and reputable dealers with proven service records in Stillwater.
Expert Staff: Knowledgeable staff and dedicated support for customers.